TheMurrow

Why Everything Costs More (or Less)

Inflation is a rate, not a feeling. Here’s what the numbers really mean—CPI vs. PCE, core vs. headline, and why prices can stay high even as inflation falls.

By TheMurrow Editorial
February 9, 2026
Why Everything Costs More (or Less)

Key Points

  • 1Understand the terms: inflation is a rising-price rate, disinflation is slower increases, and deflation is broad price declines with real risks.
  • 2Compare the gauges: CPI is the consumer headline, PCE is the Fed’s preferred index, and core/filtered measures test persistence beyond volatility.
  • 3Read releases smarter: seasonal adjustments, revisions, and your personal spending basket explain why “inflation falling” can still feel expensive.

The confusing part about inflation isn’t that prices rise. The confusing part is that inflation can “fall” while your grocery bill still feels like it’s climbing, your rent still eats half your paycheck, and a tank of gas still stings.

Inflation is a rate, not a mood. It measures how quickly prices are changing, not whether life is affordable. When inflation cools, prices usually keep rising—just more slowly. For prices across the economy to drop outright, you need something else entirely: deflation.

That distinction matters because the past few years have trained many Americans to read “inflation” as a synonym for “expensive.” It’s understandable—and it’s also wrong in a way that leads to bad expectations and worse arguments. Understanding what inflation actually is, how it’s measured, and why the numbers disagree won’t make eggs cheaper. It will make you harder to mislead.

“Inflation isn’t ‘prices are high.’ Inflation is the speedometer, not the odometer.”

— TheMurrow Editorial

Inflation, deflation, disinflation: the three words driving one debate

Inflation is a broad, sustained rise in prices across an economy. When inflation is positive, the purchasing power of a dollar falls: you need more dollars to buy the same goods and services than you did before. Economists don’t track the price of “everything.” They track price indexes—statistical measures designed to approximate a “typical basket” of purchases.

Deflation is the opposite: a broad, sustained fall in prices. A dollar buys more over time. It sounds pleasant until you notice what tends to come with it. In modern advanced economies, deflation is rare, and when it appears it often coincides with weak demand, wage pressure, or debt stress. Falling prices can encourage consumers and businesses to wait, suppressing spending and investment when the economy needs it most.

Then there’s the word that would save half the internet from misunderstanding: disinflation. Disinflation means inflation is still positive—prices are still rising—but the rate is slowing. If inflation falls from 4% to 2%, that doesn’t mean prices fell. It means prices rose more slowly.

Central banks generally prefer low, stable, predictable inflation. The European Central Bank is unusually candid about why: it frames 2% inflation as a buffer against deflation and measurement problems, and as a help for economic adjustment over time. The ECB’s emphasis on symmetry—aiming for 2% “over the medium term”—signals that a small cushion beats flirting with a zero-inflation edge where deflation risk rises. (ECB)

In the United States, the Federal Reserve’s latest policy statement (Jan. 28, 2026) said inflation remained “somewhat elevated” as it held the fed funds target range at 3.5%–3.75%. (Federal Reserve) That line—somewhat elevated—matters because it signals how officials view the direction of travel, not just the level of prices people already face.
2%
The European Central Bank frames 2% inflation as a buffer against deflation, measurement problems, and as a help for economic adjustment over time. (ECB)
3.5%–3.75%
On Jan. 28, 2026, the Federal Reserve held the fed funds target range at 3.5%–3.75% while calling inflation “somewhat elevated.” (Federal Reserve)

Why your experience doesn’t match “the inflation rate”

Households don’t buy the same basket. A renter in a city, a homeowner in the suburbs, a remote worker, and a commuter can live in the same economy while feeling different inflation. Official indexes try to measure a representative average, not your personal ledger.

“Your inflation rate is real—but it isn’t necessarily the one policymakers are paid to track.”

— TheMurrow Editorial

The “basket of goods” isn’t your cart—how price indexes work

Inflation headlines usually come from a simple idea: compare today’s prices with last year’s. The hard part lies in choosing what to compare. Price indexes approximate a basket of goods and services, assigning weights based on what households buy in aggregate. That basket is a model, not a literal shopping list.

The benefit of a model is consistency. If you want to know whether prices are rising broadly—not just whether avocados or airline tickets spiked—you need a common yardstick. The drawback is obvious: the yardstick doesn’t fit every home.

Case study: two households, two inflation stories

Consider two households with similar incomes:

- A young renter whose largest expense is rent and who spends heavily on commuting.
- A retired homeowner who owns their home outright and spends more on healthcare services.

Even if overall inflation is the same, the renter is more exposed to shelter changes and fuel. The retiree may feel inflation most sharply where services rise. Official figures aren’t “wrong” for either household; they’re averages that can miss intensity.

That gap explains why public trust frays when inflation cools on paper but budgets stay tight in practice. High prices can persist even when inflation declines, because the index measures the rate of change, not the level. Affordability doesn’t reset simply because the climb slows.

Practical takeaway

Treat inflation reports like weather maps.

A national map can tell you whether a system is moving in—but it won’t tell you whether your street flooded. Use the data for direction and trend. Use your own spending for lived reality.

CPI vs. PCE: why America has two headline inflation numbers

In the U.S., most people meet inflation through the Consumer Price Index (CPI), produced by the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS). CPI is the familiar headline, the one that moves markets on release morning and shapes political talking points by lunchtime.

Policymakers at the Federal Reserve, however, anchor their 2% goal to a different measure: the Personal Consumption Expenditures (PCE) price index, produced by the Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA). PCE covers a broader set of expenditures and uses different weights than CPI. It is also typically revised more—an advantage if you want the most accurate history, a frustration if you want clean, fixed headlines.

A concrete data point helps: the BEA reported that in January 2025, the PCE price index rose 2.5% year-over-year, and core PCE rose 2.6%. (BEA) Even when CPI and PCE point in the same direction, they can differ in level.
2.5%
BEA reported that in January 2025, the PCE price index rose 2.5% year-over-year; core PCE rose 2.6%. (BEA)

Why do they disagree?

The short version is composition and methodology:

- Different weights: CPI and PCE don’t assume households allocate spending the same way.
- Different scope: PCE includes a wider range of expenditures.
- Different revision practices: PCE tends to be revised more, which can smooth or alter prior readings.

None of that means one is honest and the other is propaganda. It means each was built for a slightly different purpose—CPI for a consumer-facing snapshot, PCE for a broader, policy-focused view.

“CPI tells a sharp story fast. PCE tells a broader story—and edits it later.”

— TheMurrow Editorial

Core inflation: the most misunderstood subtraction in economics

When inflation feels personal, “core” can feel like an insult. Core inflation strips out food and energy because those prices can swing sharply from month to month. The goal isn’t to dismiss grocery bills or gas prices; it’s to see whether the underlying trend is persistent.

Defenders argue that monetary policy shouldn’t whip around every time energy prices jump, especially when those moves can be driven by global shocks outside a central bank’s control. Critics respond with a fair point: households can’t exclude food and energy. People live in the headline economy, not the core economy.

The tension is real, and it helps explain why policymakers reference both measures. Headline inflation tells you what is happening now to total costs. Core inflation tries to tell you what is likely to keep happening once temporary spikes fade.

Expert perspective: why central banks care about persistence

A central bank’s job is not to subsidize pain; it is to steer demand and expectations. Food and energy can be volatile; policy tools are blunt and slow. Filtering volatility can help officials avoid overreacting and accidentally causing more economic damage than the original spike.

At the same time, ignoring lived experience can erode legitimacy. A sensible reading is that headline inflation drives public sentiment, while core inflation informs policy strategy.

Practical takeaway

Use core as a trendline, not a replacement.

If you want to understand momentum, core helps. If you want to understand your household squeeze, headline matters. The mistake is treating either as the single “true” inflation rate.

“Supercore,” trimmed mean, and median CPI: removing noise without losing the signal

If core inflation is one filter, economists have built others. Some approaches aim to remove the most extreme price changes—up or down—so that a handful of wild categories don’t dominate the overall reading.

The Cleveland Federal Reserve publishes two widely cited measures:

- Median CPI
- 16% trimmed-mean CPI

For December 2025, Cleveland Fed data show Median CPI at 3.1% year-over-year and the 16% trimmed mean at 3.0% year-over-year. (Cleveland Fed) Those figures matter not because they are magic, but because they illustrate persistence. When headline inflation swings due to a few volatile categories, median and trimmed-mean measures can reveal whether inflation pressure is broad.
3.1%
For December 2025, Cleveland Fed data show Median CPI at 3.1% year-over-year and 16% trimmed mean at 3.0% year-over-year. (Cleveland Fed)

How these measures work in plain English

A trimmed-mean measure lops off the biggest price moves—both increases and decreases—then averages what remains. Median CPI finds the middle category: half of prices are rising faster, half slower.

The point isn’t to create a better headline for public relations. The point is diagnostic. If inflation looks high because a narrow set of prices is surging, the policy response might differ from a world where inflation is embedded across many categories.

Practical takeaway

If you want “sticky inflation,” look at filtered measures.

People searching for whether inflation is “really” coming down often want to know if it’s persistent. Median and trimmed-mean indicators are designed for exactly that question.

Seasonal adjustments and revisions: why the numbers sometimes “jump” on paper

Inflation reporting has another layer that confuses even attentive readers: seasonal adjustment. Many prices follow predictable annual patterns—holiday travel, back-to-school clothing, winter heating. Seasonal adjustments attempt to remove those recurring patterns so month-to-month changes better reflect underlying movement.

The BLS recalculates seasonal factors each year with the January CPI. That process can revise seasonally adjusted indexes for the previous five years. For the January 2026 CPI, revisions covering Jan 2021–Dec 2025 were scheduled to be published alongside the release. (BLS)

Revisions don’t mean the data were fabricated and later “fixed.” They mean statisticians updated the model as new information accumulated—like improving the calibration of an instrument.

A news-specific wrinkle: the January 2026 CPI delay

Because of a funding lapse/partial shutdown, the BLS delayed the January 2026 CPI release to Friday, Feb. 13, 2026 at 8:30 a.m. ET. (BLS) Readers looking for the “latest inflation number” should know that timing, and should also know what comes with it: the annual seasonal-factor update and revisions.
Feb. 13, 2026
Because of a funding lapse/partial shutdown, BLS delayed the January 2026 CPI release to Friday, Feb. 13, 2026 at 8:30 a.m. ET. (BLS)

Practical takeaway

Don’t overreact to one month.

Month-to-month inflation can move due to seasonal factor changes even if underlying price behavior is stable. For interpretation, year-over-year rates and multi-month trends usually carry more meaning than a single monthly print.

What the Fed and ECB are really aiming for—and why 2% won

A common public frustration sounds reasonable: why not aim for zero inflation? If inflation erodes purchasing power, wouldn’t zero be ideal?

Central banks have answered that question in practice by choosing a small positive target, commonly 2%. The ECB explicitly frames 2% as a buffer against deflation and measurement issues and as helpful for macroeconomic adjustment. (ECB) In other words, a little inflation grease helps wages and prices adjust without requiring outright cuts that can be economically and politically painful.

In the U.S., the Federal Reserve’s January 28, 2026 statement held rates at 3.5%–3.75% and described inflation as “somewhat elevated.” (Federal Reserve) The level of rates isn’t the same as the inflation rate, but the message matters: policy remains restrictive enough to lean against inflation that officials still view as above comfort.

Multiple perspectives: what critics and defenders get right

Skeptics argue that any steady inflation is a quiet tax on savers, and they’re not wrong about the arithmetic. Defenders argue that the alternative—regular flirtation with deflation—can be worse, especially in debt-heavy economies where falling prices raise the real burden of what people owe.

Both sides share a hidden premise: inflation is never just a statistic. It reshapes bargaining power, expectations, and politics. That’s why a 2% target is less a moral claim than a risk-management choice.

How to read the next inflation headline like an adult

Inflation literacy isn’t about memorizing acronyms. It’s about asking better questions than the headline invites.

When you see an inflation number, read it in three passes:

1. Level vs. direction: Are prices still rising, just more slowly (disinflation), or actually falling (deflation)?
2. Measure: Is the headline CPI or the Fed’s preferred PCE? Are you looking at headline or core?
3. Breadth: Are filtered measures (median, trimmed mean) telling a similar story about persistence?

Then connect it back to your own household basket. If your largest expense is rent, you will care about shelter dynamics more than a commuter who cares about fuel. If you recently renewed insurance or bought a car, your personal inflation can be unusually high even in a cooling economy.

Three passes to read any inflation headline

  1. 1.Level vs. direction: Are prices still rising more slowly (disinflation), or actually falling (deflation)?
  2. 2.Measure: Is it CPI or PCE—and headline or core?
  3. 3.Breadth: Do filtered measures (median, trimmed mean) agree about persistence?

A simple, realistic expectation to hold

When inflation falls, relief often arrives as slower increases—not as a rewind to old prices. That can still matter. Slower inflation gives wages a chance to catch up. It allows planning. It reduces the pressure for aggressive rate hikes that can trigger job losses.

The price level is where you live. The inflation rate is where policymakers steer.

Conclusion: inflation is a story about change, not just cost

Inflation debates turn toxic when people argue past the same word. “Inflation” can mean a rate, a feeling, a political accusation, or a personal budget crisis. The official definition is narrower: a broad, sustained rise in prices, measured by imperfect but useful indexes.

Those indexes disagree for intelligible reasons. CPI and PCE weigh the world differently. Core and “supercore” measures strip volatility to find persistence. Seasonal adjustments revise the recent past because the economy isn’t a lab experiment—it’s a moving target.

Once you internalize that, the headlines get less hypnotic. You stop expecting falling inflation to mean falling prices. You stop treating one month’s number as a verdict. You start looking for what actually matters: whether price increases are broad, whether they’re persistent, and whether your own household basket is drifting away from the average.

The next time someone says inflation is “back to normal,” ask a sharper question: normal for which measure, over what time frame, and for whom?
T
About the Author
TheMurrow Editorial is a writer for TheMurrow covering explainers.

Frequently Asked Questions

What’s the difference between “high prices” and “high inflation”?

High prices describe the level of costs today. High inflation describes the rate at which those prices are rising. Prices can stay high even when inflation falls, because disinflation means prices are still increasing—just more slowly. For prices across the economy to fall broadly, you would need deflation.

Why does my inflation feel higher than the official inflation rate?

Official inflation is based on an average “basket” of spending. Your household basket can be very different depending on rent vs. homeownership, commuting habits, family size, or healthcare needs. If your biggest spending categories rise faster than average, your personal inflation will feel higher—even if the official rate is cooling.

What’s the difference between CPI and PCE, and why does the Fed prefer PCE?

CPI (from the BLS) is the most widely reported consumer inflation gauge. PCE (from the BEA) covers a broader set of expenditures, uses different weights, and is typically revised more. The Fed’s 2% inflation framework is built around PCE because it is designed to better reflect overall consumer spending patterns across the economy.

What does “core inflation” mean, and is it misleading?

Core inflation excludes food and energy prices because they can swing sharply month to month. Supporters argue it helps identify the underlying trend policymakers can influence. Critics argue it can feel disconnected from everyday life because households can’t avoid groceries or gas. A fair approach: use headline inflation for lived costs and core for persistence.

What are “median CPI” and “trimmed-mean CPI” used for?

These measures, published by the Cleveland Fed, remove the impact of extreme price moves to better track persistent inflation. For December 2025, the Cleveland Fed reported Median CPI at 3.1% year-over-year and 16% trimmed-mean CPI at 3.0%. They’re useful when headline inflation is distorted by a small number of volatile categories.

Why do inflation numbers get revised?

Revisions often come from updates to seasonal adjustment factors and improved statistical estimates as more data arrive. The BLS recalculates seasonal adjustments annually with the January CPI and can revise seasonally adjusted indexes for the prior five years. Revisions don’t imply bad faith; they reflect updated modeling to better isolate underlying price trends.

More in Explainers

You Might Also Like